Canadian Pizza Magazine

Tweaked to perfection

Colleen Cross   

Features Profiles

Attention to detail helped win Fernando D’Agostino a place on the Chef of the Year podium

Fernando D’Agostino displays his artfully arranged Sidernese pizza. Photo by Malcolm Brown

Last October, Fernando D’Agostino did himself and his boss proud, putting together a signature pie that landed him in third place at the Canadian Pizza Chef of the Year competition sponsored by Saputo Foodservice and Moretti Forni.

“It was already on our menu, but we tweaked it a bit,” says the slightly shy young chef.

It was D’Agostino’s first pizza competition and he seems to take the pressure in stride. “We had the dough ready-made and the ingredients prepared,” he says. “If anything, using a different oven in an unfamiliar setting was the biggest challenge.”

D’Agostino has worked at That’s Italian Ristorante in Woodbridge, Ont., for the past two years.


It was restaurant owner Joe Lombardi’s idea for Fernando to enter the competition and Lombardi’s recipe made it to the podium with him, D’Agostino says. Lombardi says his superstar pizzaiolo was able to channel his pride in what he does to overcome his modesty and excel on the competition floor.

The restaurant, which opened a smaller location called That’s Italian Express in Richmond Hill in October 2013, has been in business since 2008. Lombardi is part of Toronto pizza history, his father having opened Regina (an offshoot of city institution Vesuvio’s) on College Street in 1982.

Many of the restaurant’s customers – particularly those in Richmond Hill – are of Asian background, Lombardi says, and many are well travelled and looking for an authentic Italian eating experience that matches their old-country experience. They seem to really appreciate the food, he says, often asking staff which items they recommend, snapping photos of their dishes and expressing delight when offered a frequent-customer perk such as a complimentary limoncello liqueur.

D’Agostino likes his work and especially the fact that at That’s Italian, pizza is treated with just as much importance as any item on the menu. It’s not just an afterthought, he says. “It makes me feel appreciated,” he says.

He doesn’t have formal chef training, but started his working career as a teenager at a local Brampton, Ont., pizzeria where he and his family ate every Friday night.

“My parents asked if they would give me a job,” D’Agostino says. While the food business was not a deliberate choice of vocation, he warmed to the work as he gradually took on more and more responsibility.

The Sidernese is named for the town of Siderno in the Calabria region of Italy. D’Agostino enjoys making this house specialty pizza because it demands extra attention to detail and extra time spent to make it visually appealing.

“You have to place everything evenly, and you can’t have two much of one topping in one spot,” he says.

D’Agostino loves to play tennis in his spare time. And when he’s not whipping up thin-crust pizzas himself, the young foodie enjoys checking out pizzas at other restaurants.

He says, “Sometimes people ask me if they would like a certain topping on a pizza. I don’t think there are any limitations on pizza. I tell them, “If you like something off a pizza, you’ll like it on a pizza.”

Indeed, there seem few limits to what this pizzaiolo can do.

The Sidernese
Here is Fernando D’Agostino’s third-place recipe for Canadian Pizza Chef of the Year.


  • pizza dough, store-bought or homemade
  • fresh baby arugula
  • buffalo mozzarella
  • oven-dried (or sun-dried) tomatoes
  • Italian prosciutto crudo
  • shaved Parmigiano Reggiano or Grano Padano
  • extra virgin olive oil
  • flour


  • pizza stone or baking sheet
  • pizza peel (or the back of a baking sheet)


  1. Heat the oven to 550 F or higher: Don’t be afraid to really crank the heat up to its highest setting. The high heat will help make a crunchier and more flavourful crust. Let the oven heat for at least a half an hour before baking your pizzas. If you have a baking stone, place it in the lower-middle area of your oven.
  2. Roll out the dough:
    Method 1: Baking stone – Sprinkle a handful of flour on a pizza peel or the back of a baking sheet. Use your hands or a rolling pin to flatten the pizza dough until it is 1/4-inch thick or less. Shake the peel or baking sheet often as you shape to make sure the dough isn’t sticking. If the dough starts to shrink back, let it rest for five minutes and then continue rolling.
    Method 2: Baking sheet – Brush a thin film of olive oil on a baking sheet. Use your hands or a rolling pin to flatten the dough until it is 1/4-inch thick or less. Place it on the sheet. If the dough starts to shrink back, let it rest for five minutes and then continue rolling.
  3. Top the pizza: Spread your mozzarella cheese evenly on your pizza.  The rest of the toppings will be put on the pizza in stages.
  4. Bake the pizza: Using a pizza peel or the backside of a baking sheet, slide your pizza onto the baking stone. If you don’t have a baking stone, bake the pizza right on the baking sheet. Cook for 10 minutes. Pull the pizza out and top with the buffalo mozzarella. It melts quickly and doesn’t need a lot of time in the oven.
    Bake for another three to five minutes, until the crust is golden-brown and the cheese looks toasty.
    Once the pizza comes out of the oven, top it with the arugula. You can toss the arugula in a light vinaigrette before applying as well. Next, top the pizza with the thinly sliced prosciutto and shaved Parmigiana Reggiano.
  5. Slice and serve: Let the pizza cool slightly on a cooling rack.

Print this page


Stories continue below